What should you settle before asking an architect for more space?

By

Answering: Before asking an architect for more space, what should a household settle about how the house must work in 10 to 20 years?

Estimated reading time: 11 min read

In Victoria, an extension that adds more than the lesser of 25 per cent or 1,000 square metres to a home’s floor area must meet the livable housing provisions of the National Construction Code, according to the Building and Plumbing Commission. That makes how you will live in the house part of the brief for more space from its first line, so settle five things before you ask an architect for it: who will live there and for how long, which rooms must work without stairs, whether the house needs room for a lift, what belongs in stage one, and when you want to decide.

Late decisions are easy to draw and hard to undo. A bedroom reached by stairs or a shower with a step into it can be designed in an afternoon, then lived with for twenty years. An architect can design for any answer you give, and only the answers you bring can shape the design from the start.

If you are a couple planning to stay on into your eighties, and you can fund the work without waiting on a lender’s approval, the timetable is yours to set. The practice’s ageing-in-place page describes the advantage this way: you can “make the decisions calmly, choose when the builders come, and reach your seventies in a home that simply works.”

Barbara Yerondais, a fixed-fee renovation and extension architect who leads BY Projects Architecture in Melbourne, agrees her fee for architectural services, and the scope it covers, before any design starts, so your answers here become the brief that fee is fixed against. Our guide to what one hour settles before a design contract explains why a fee is only as good as the brief behind it.

Key Insights

  • In Victoria, an extension adding more than the lesser of 25 per cent or 1,000 square metres of floor area must meet the National Construction Code’s livable housing provisions, so future use belongs in the first brief.
  • Five decisions come before a brief for more space: who lives here and for how long, which rooms must work without stairs, whether to leave room for a lift, what belongs in stage one, and when to decide.
  • Bringing the main bedroom, a full bathroom and everyday living onto one level can mean you never need a lift; otherwise a lift can be planned for as space in the structure.
  • Barbara Yerondais, a fixed-fee renovation and extension architect, agrees her fee for architectural services before any design starts, so these answers become the brief that fee is fixed against.
Decision The question to answer What it changes in the brief
1. Who and how long Who lives here now, who may join or leave, and for how many years? The time horizon the whole design is judged against
2. Level living Which rooms must you reach without stairs? Whether the plan puts the main bedroom, a full bathroom and everyday living on one level
3. A way between floors Would a lift ever be wanted, and where could it go? Whether space is set aside in the structure, or the plan avoids stairs altogether
4. Staging What is stage one, and what can wait? The scope the fee is fixed against and the order of the work
5. Timing When do you want to decide and start, and what sets the pace? How much room you have to weigh your options

Table of Contents

1. Who lives here, and for how long?

Start with the people. Write down who lives in the house today, who is likely to live in it in ten years, and who might stay for a season, such as an adult child between rentals or a parent who needs company. The answer sets the horizon the design is judged against, because a house for two people who plan to stay into their eighties asks for different things from a house for a family who expect to sell in eight years.

The practice’s ageing in place page begins from the same question: “Renovate, extend or build a home that works beautifully now and adapts as your needs change.” The Australian Building Codes Board’s Livable Housing Design Standard sets technical provisions that help dwellings “better meet the needs of the community, including older people and people with mobility limitations.” How far your own house should go beyond that baseline is a decision only you can make.

Three questions put it on paper:

  • Who lives here now, and how well does the house suit each of them?
  • Who might join or leave in the next ten to twenty years?
  • How long do you honestly expect to stay?

Check before you move on: can you say in one sentence who the house is for today, and in another who it is for in ten years?

2. Which rooms must work without stairs?

This decision settles where new space goes. The practice’s ageing-in-place page states the target: “the main bedroom, a full bathroom and everyday living on the entry level, so the stairs become optional.” It also names a route that can make a lift unnecessary: “A well-placed rear addition can bring the main bedroom, bathroom and living spaces onto one level and leave the front of the house alone. That can mean you never need a lift at all.”

For the house you have, the same page says: “Often the answer is a replan rather than more floor area: moving the bedroom, opening up the circulation and rebuilding one bathroom properly.” If the rooms you need already fit on the entry level, you may be asking for a replan rather than more space.

The building rules treat existing houses with some flexibility. The Building and Plumbing Commission explains that Building Regulation 233 gives the relevant building surveyor discretion over how much of an existing building must be upgraded, including consent to partial compliance. The whole building must be upgraded only where the alterations, counted with any done in the previous three years, exceed 50 per cent of the original building volume, and even then the surveyor can consent to partial compliance. Which rooms you need on one level is your decision, and what the rules ask of the existing house depends on the work and the surveyor.

  • Which bedroom would you use if stairs became hard?
  • Which bathroom would you use, and can it hold a step-free shower?
  • Where would everyday living, the kitchen and the laundry sit in relation to them?

Check before you move on: do the rooms you named already sit on one level, and if they do not, where would an addition or a replan put them?

3. Is there room for a lift, now or later?

A lift is a question of space long before it is a question of equipment. The practice’s ageing-in-place page gives the options for a house that has stairs: “an internal lift in a secondary space or the footprint of a cupboard run, or rooms built now to take a lift later.” Its answer to whether you can add a lift to an existing house is “Often, yes,” followed by a question worth asking first: do you need one at all, because bringing everything onto one level is usually the simpler answer.

A new home at Military Road, Avondale Heights, designed by Barbara Yerondais’s practice, shows the idea settled early. Store rooms on the ground and first floors were designed structurally so the floor between them can be removed for a future lift, with the pit already built in. That project is a new build, so it shows the principle in its simplest form and promises nothing about an existing house. The useful part for your brief is the order of events: the space was decided in the design, and a lift supplier specifies the equipment once the design has made room for it.

So the decision has three answers: a lift now, a lift later with the structure ready for it, or no lift because one level will do. Each asks something different of the plan.

Check before you move on: can you say whether a lift is wanted now, wanted later or not wanted, and roughly where on each floor the answer would put it?

4. What is stage one, and what can wait?

A brief for more space tends to grow on the way to the drawing board, and a stage list stops it. Barbara Yerondais’s staged method is built for that sorting. Once you have signed her client agreement, it begins with schematics and then shows you two options: what your budget achieves and what your dream costs, with a shopping list so you can decide what is in and what is out.

Your first three answers feed straight into this one. The rooms that must work on one level are usually stage one. A space reserved for a lift is a structural provision, so it belongs in the stage that builds the structure even if the lift itself arrives years later.

Bring the list with you when you meet an architect, along with your title and any existing plans. Our guide to what to bring to a first meeting with an architect covers the documents.

  • Stage one: the rooms and structure you cannot do without.
  • Provision for later: what the structure should allow now, such as space for a lift.
  • Left out: what you have been carrying from a magazine and no longer need.

Check before you move on: could you hand someone a list headed stage one, provision for later and left out?

5. When do you want to decide, and who sets the pace?

The last decision is about time. The practice’s ageing-in-place page puts the position of a household that does not need finance approval in one line: “If the work is funded from savings or the sale of another property rather than a loan, no bank valuation or loan approval sets the timetable, so you can start when the design is right.” The same page adds that a fee agreed before design starts, a builder’s price you can compare line by line and the building surveyor’s inspections at the mandatory stages matter more when no lender is watching.

Design and permits take time, so starting early leaves room to weigh the options above. Consumer Affairs Victoria tells owners that it is their obligation to find out whether the work needs planning and building permits, and that a project costing more than $10,000 requires the builder to use a major domestic building contract.

  • The date you would like to be living in the finished house.
  • Anything outside your household that sets the pace, such as a sale or a lender.
  • Who in the household holds the final say on each decision.

Check before you move on: do you know your preferred start, and what, if anything, could move it?

Who can help with this

These decisions touch several people’s work, and the project runs best when they all work from one plan.

  • Barbara Yerondais, a fixed-fee renovation and extension architect, works out what the house, the budget and the planning scheme will allow, then designs it and holds the whole picture together.
  • A builder prices and builds the work, including any structure set aside for later.
  • A building surveyor issues the building permit and, on an existing house, decides how far the livable housing provisions apply.
  • A lift supplier specifies the equipment once the design has made room for it.
  • An occupational therapist can assess a specific health or mobility need if someone in the household already has one, and that advice goes straight into the brief.

Closing

Before you ask an architect for more space, settle who the house is for and for how long, which rooms must work without stairs, whether a lift is wanted, what belongs in stage one and when you want to decide. Those five answers turn a wish for more space into a brief. Barbara Yerondais’s approach is to work out what suits your house, your plans and your budget, and to agree a fixed fee for architectural services before any design starts, so the answers you bring are the brief the fee and the design are built on. Write them on one page, then talk to Barbara while the timing is still yours.

Frequently asked questions about planning for future use

Q: What should I decide before I ask an architect for more space?

A: Five things: who will live in the house and for how long, which rooms must work without stairs, whether a lift is ever wanted, what belongs in stage one, and when you want to decide and start. Written on one page, they become the brief that an architect’s fee can be fixed against. In Victoria they matter early because a large enough extension must meet the livable housing provisions of the National Construction Code.

Q: Does extending a Victorian home trigger accessibility requirements?

A: Sometimes. The Building and Plumbing Commission explains that an extension increasing the floor area by more than the lesser of 25 per cent or 1,000 square metres must comply with the livable housing provisions, and the whole building must be upgraded only where alterations exceed 50 per cent of the original building volume. In both cases the relevant building surveyor can consent to partial compliance for the existing building.

Q: Do I need a lift if I plan to stay for decades?

A: Not necessarily. The practice’s answer is that a compact internal lift can sit in a secondary space or the footprint of a cupboard run, and that bringing the main bedroom, a full bathroom and everyday living onto one level is usually the simpler answer. If a lift may be wanted later, the structure can be designed to take one, which is a decision for the design stage.

Q: What is the first step if we are planning to stay for decades?

A: Talk to Barbara. A free, no-obligation call comes first, and if the project is a fit, the one-hour Feasibility Session follows. In the practice’s own words: “In one hour with Barbara Yerondais, FRAIA, in person or on Zoom, you’ll talk through your site, budget and planning timelines, and leave knowing what’s realistic and what your next step is. There’s no obligation to go further.”

Citations

About the Author

Barbara Yerondais, FRAIA, is the founder of BY Projects Architecture. With 35+ years of experience, she specializes in sustainable, community-focused design and heritage restoration. A dedicated mentor and rower, Barbara balances her high-impact Melbourne practice with a passion for social inclusion and passive, energy-saving design.

INDEX

Start the Conversation

Every project begins with a deep inquiry into site, heritage, and vision. Let’s discuss the strategic potential of your next work.

SCHEDULE A FEASIBILITY SESSION →

A PRELIMINARY CONSULTATION TO EVALUATE HERITAGE CONSTRAINTS, SITE POTENTIAL, AND PROJECT FEASIBILITY.